The true cost of rent-to-own is everything you pay over the life of the lease, and that number can be far above the price on the tag. Keep a 12-month lease to the end and a sofa, a TV or a washer may cost you around twice its cash price. Buying the item early through an early purchase option usually costs much less, as long as you do it within the time the contract allows.
Lease-to-own is also in the news this month. On November 12, 2026, attorneys general from 43 states announced a $183.5 million settlement with Acima Digital, LLC and its parent company, Acima Holdings, LLC. The states alleged that Acima misled shoppers about the true nature and cost of its agreements. Offers like these show up at checkout in furniture, electronics and appliance stores, and they are often aimed at people who may not qualify for a store card or a loan.
How does rent-to-own work?
In a rent-to-own deal, which may also be called lease-to-own or a rental-purchase agreement, you rent the item a week, two weeks or a month at a time. Each payment renews the lease for another period. The company keeps ownership until you have made every payment or bought the item out early. You can usually stop paying and give it back, but you generally don’t get back what you already paid.
Because it is a lease, there is normally no interest rate in the contract. What you see instead is a “cost of rental” or “cost of lease,” the gap between the cash price and the total you would pay to own the item.
Most contracts give you three choices. You can make every payment until the term ends and own the item, buy it sooner with the early purchase option, or return it and walk away. If you want to keep it, the early purchase option is the part of the contract to read first. The Acima consent judgment gives a sense of how these options can be priced. Under the options offered when the judgment was signed, a shopper who bought within 90 days would pay the cash price plus a $70 charge. After 90 days, the shopper could buy the item by paying 75% of the total remaining lease payments.
What did the Acima settlement allege?
The states alleged that Acima marketed its rental-purchase agreements as 90-day payoff programs without telling shoppers that they would be placed in the maximum 12-month term if they didn’t act. According to the Alaska Department of Law, consumers on that longer term “could pay approximately two times the cash price advertised by Acima’s retail partner.”
The coalition made several other claims. It said Acima used words like “credit” in its ads, which could lead people to think they were getting traditional financing. It also said the electronic signing process obscured the terms, that Acima marked up the cash price from the retailers’ prices, and that it got in the way of people who tried to end their agreements by returning the merchandise. No court ruled on them. The Colorado consent judgment says Acima entered into it to settle “a disputed matter” and that Acima “specifically denies any such wrongdoing or liability.”
| Settlement detail | What the official releases say |
|---|---|
| Announced | November 12, 2026 (Colorado); November 13, 2026 (Alaska) |
| States | 43 attorneys general, including Utah, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Texas and Florida |
| Total value | $183.5 million |
| Consumer restitution | $43 million |
| Lease balance reductions | $130 million |
| Payment to the states | $10.5 million |
| Credit reporting | No reporting of rental-purchase agreements to the three major credit bureaus for five years |
| What consumers must do | Nothing; the settlement administrator contacts people due restitution, and Acima contacts people due lease forgiveness |
Under the consent judgment, Acima also agreed to stop marking up the cash price from its retail partners’ prices and to stop obstructing returns that end an agreement. If you had an Acima lease, watch your mail and email for a notice, and be careful with anyone who asks for a fee to “release” a settlement payment.
Separately, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau sued Acima in July 2024, alleging among other things that its leases were credit. On March 6, 2025, the CFPB filed a notice dismissing that case with prejudice, so it ended without a ruling on those claims.
Why can rent-to-own cost so much more than the cash price?
Each payment covers the use of the item for one period, and the full term is priced to cover the item, the company’s risk and its profit. The example below is hypothetical, and all of its figures are assumptions rather than the terms of any real company.
Say a sectional sofa has a cash price of $1,000. The lease is 12 months long, with 26 payments of $77 every two weeks. The contract also lets you buy the sofa within 90 days for the cash price plus a $50 fee, with payments already made counting toward that amount.
| Path (hypothetical) | What you pay in total | Compared with the $1,000 cash price |
|---|---|---|
| Buy within 90 days | $1,050 | $50 more |
| Keep the full 12-month lease | $2,002 | $1,002 more |
| Pay 6 times, then return the sofa | $462 | You own nothing |
In this example, the same sofa costs $1,050 or $2,002, and one deadline decides which. If you miss the early purchase window, the agreement keeps running, and in the Acima case the states alleged that this was not disclosed to shoppers.
Is rent-to-own the same as BNPL or a store credit card?
No. Rent-to-own is a lease, while buy now, pay later and store credit cards are forms of credit, and that affects cost, ownership and what happens if you stop paying. The table uses the same $1,000 purchase and assumed rates.
| Option | Do you own the item right away? | How the cost works | Hypothetical total for $1,000 over 12 months or less |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rent-to-own | No, the company owns it until you finish or buy out | Cost of rental instead of interest; early purchase option can cut it | $1,050 if bought in 90 days; $2,002 if kept 12 months |
| Buy now, pay later (pay in 4) | Yes | Often no interest if paid on time; late fees vary by provider | $1,000 in four payments of $250, if no fees apply |
| Store card with deferred interest | Yes | No interest if paid in full by the end of the promo; otherwise interest back to the purchase date | $1,000 if paid off in time; more if any balance remains |
| Credit card at an assumed 24% APR | Yes | Interest on the balance you carry | About $1,135 with 12 equal monthly payments |
| Personal loan at an assumed 15% APR, no fee | Yes | Fixed payments; fees can raise the cost | About $1,083 with 12 equal monthly payments |
If you are weighing pay-in-four plans against a card this season, our guide to BNPL vs credit cards for holiday shopping goes through that choice in detail.
Store cards with deferred interest work differently from a plain 0% offer. The CFPB explains that with a deferred interest plan, if you haven’t paid off the balance by the end of the promotional period, “you would owe all of the interest back to the original date of the charge.”
A personal loan can be cheaper than a long lease for people who qualify, but the APR and fees matter. Our article on comparing personal loan APRs when fees are buried in the fine print shows how to check the real cost, and how to size a personal loan for a large purchase helps you borrow only what you need.

What rules apply to rent-to-own in your state?
Rent-to-own is mostly a matter of state law, so what protects you depends on where you live. Many states have a law written just for rental-purchase agreements. Colorado’s is the Colorado Rental Purchase Agreement Act, and the settlement requires Acima to follow it.
New York’s rules show what this can look like. The New York Attorney General says the total of payments under a rental-purchase agreement “cannot be more than 2.25 times the cash price.” The contract there has to list the cash price, the cost of rental and the total of payments, along with a chart of early purchase amounts. New York shoppers also have a right to buy early and, in some cases, a right to reinstatement. Other states can set very different rules, so look up the law in yours.
If a lease-to-own company seems to have broken those rules, your state attorney general’s consumer protection office takes complaints. Deceptive practices can also be reported to the Federal Trade Commission.
What to check before you sign a lease-to-own agreement
Before you sign, compare two numbers. One is the cash price, and it is worth asking the store what it would charge you to pay for the item today, since the states claimed Acima had marked up cash prices from what its retail partners charged. The other is the total you would pay if you kept the lease to the end, counting every payment plus any processing or delivery fees. If the second number is close to double the first, you are looking at the kind of cost the Alaska Department of Law described in the Acima case.
Then find the early purchase option in the contract. It tells you how long the early buyout lasts and what it costs. Check also whether you have to contact the company to use it, because some leases move into the full term on their own if you say nothing. Put the last day on your calendar.
Returns and payments are worth a look too. The contract should explain how to give the item back and whether you pay for pickup or any fees. Many of these leases draw payments automatically from a bank account or card, so it helps to know the dates and keep enough money in the account to avoid an overdraft. Finally, ask whether the company reports on-time payments to the credit bureaus. If it doesn’t, the lease won’t help you build credit.

What to do this week
If a holiday purchase has you looking at rent-to-own, start by writing down two numbers: the cash price and the total cost to own. Then hold them up against at least one other option from the table above. People who already have a lease should look up their early purchase deadline and ask for the current buyout amount. And if you had an Acima agreement, watch for a notice from the settlement administrator or from Acima itself.
Disclaimer: This article is for general educational purposes and is not financial or legal advice. The hypothetical figures are illustrations, not the terms of any company, and rent-to-own rules vary by state. Confirm costs in your own contract and check your state attorney general’s website for the rules where you live.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is rent-to-own a loan?
Usually not. Rent-to-own is normally set up as a lease, so the company owns the item until you finish paying or buy it out. The contract shows a cost of rental on top of the cash price instead of interest.
How much more does rent-to-own cost than buying outright?
That depends on the contract and on your state’s law. In the Acima settlement, the states alleged that shoppers who stayed on the 12-month term could pay about twice the advertised cash price.
What is an early purchase option?
It is the right to buy the item for a set amount before the lease ends. When a contract offers a 90-day option, using it within those first 90 days is usually the cheapest way to own the item.
Do I need to do anything to get money from the Acima settlement?
No. The state attorneys general say the settlement administrator will contact people eligible for restitution, and Acima will contact people eligible for lease forgiveness.
Does rent-to-own build credit?
Not always. Some lease-to-own companies don’t report payments to the major credit bureaus. Under the settlement, Acima can’t report rental-purchase agreements to the three major bureaus for five years.
Sources
- Colorado Attorney General: $183.5 million multistate settlement with Acima Digital, LLC, November 12, 2026 (coag.gov/press-releases)
- Colorado Attorney General: Acima multistate consent judgment, Exhibit A (coag.gov/app/uploads)
- Alaska Department of Law: Multistate settlement with Acima Digital, LLC, November 13, 2026 (law.alaska.gov/press/releases)
- CFPB: Enforcement action, Acima Holdings, LLC and Acima Digital, LLC (www.consumerfinance.gov/enforcement/actions/acima-allred)
- New York Attorney General: Consumer purchases, rent-to-own (ag.ny.gov/resources/individuals/consumer-issues/purchases)
- CFPB: What is a deferred interest promotion? (www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb)
- FTC: Report fraud (reportfraud.ftc.gov)